Before you submit. This sets realistic expectations and saves everyone time.
We're Collectors Running a Business
To offer what we do β fair quotes in 24 hours, no listing grind, both cash and consignment paths β we have to buy at a margin. We are not paying retail. If you need retail dollar for every piece, list them yourself on eBay β that's a totally valid choice.
The Math on a Buy-Outright Offer
Our typical cash-today offer lands around 40-60% of the eBay sold-comp average for your pieces. That % covers what a reseller eats that a private seller doesn't:
- Platform fees β eBay / Whatnot take 13-15% when we turn around and sell
- Payment processing β another 2-3%
- Inventory holding β some pieces sit 6-12 months before the right buyer shows up
- Shipping materials + labor β bubble wrap, boxes, corner protectors, labels, packing time
- Risk β returns, damage, mis-grades, the occasional chargeback
- Your time β the hours you skip photographing, listing, writing descriptions, answering buyer DMs
eBay sold-comp average for your piece$100
Platform + payment fees eBay takes from us on resaleβ β$16
Shipping materials / labor per pieceβ β$5
Inventory risk / hold costβ β$10
Typical buy-outright offer to you$40 β $60
Consignment β You Get More
On consignment we list, photograph, market, and ship your pieces. You get back 65-80% of the eBay sold-comp after our commission. Trade-off: longer timeline β you get paid when the piece sells, not today.
Same $100 piece, sold on consignment$100
Our commission (typically 25%)β β$25
What you net$70 β $80
What This Means For You
- Expect our outright quote on a $100 eBay piece to land around $40-$60
- Expect a consignment payout of around $70-$80 (whenever it sells)
- Rare grails, sealed cases, and case-fresh pieces get higher %
- Bulk common pieces (common-wave Elites, loose modern figures) get lower %
- If you're hoping for 90%+ of retail in cash, we're not your path β list it yourself
Still a Fair Deal?
Depends on your math. Here's what you're trading:
- Time saved (no listings, no photos, no buyer messages, no shipping)
- Zero platform fees or chargeback risk on your end
- Cash in 24 hours (outright) or guaranteed market visibility (consignment)
- One conversation vs fifty
For some sellers that's worth it. For others it's not. We'd rather you know going in than be disappointed at the quote. Not sure which way to go? See how to decide whether to keep or sell a figure and how to find action figure values.